The vice presidency in America as a challenge to representative democracy: the cases of the US, Brazil and Argentina
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24201/fi.v62i1.2809Keywords:
Latin America, United States, representative democracy, legitimacy, vice presidentAbstract
Since the Third Wave of democratization, political science has extensively debated the performance of the presidential model in Latin America and its effects on democratic stability. However, that debate has ignored a key figure: the vice presidency. The objective of this article is to reflect on this position, which exists practically throughout the Americas, as a challenge to the representative character of democracy, in connection with the existing debate on presidentialism and the political stability of American democracies. Based on three cases—Brazil, Argentina and the United States—this article considers the fixed character of the role (not removable by the president) and the mechanisms provided for his election as factors that diminish the representative character of the vice presidency and lead to instability and a lack of legitimacy of the Executive. Drawing on these factors, this article concludes there is a need to introduce reforms to the vice presidency, or consider its replacement by another mode of succession.
Downloads
References
ANDREONI, M., “Michel Temer, Brazil’s Deeply Unpopular President, Signals Run for a New Term”, The New York Times, 24 de marzo de 2018, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/24/world/americas/brazil-michel-temer.html
ARAGÓN REYES, M., Estudios sobre el Parlamento, Ciudad de México, UNAM, Instituto de Investigaciones Jurídicas y Cámara de Diputados, 2017.
ARMESTO, D., “El vicepresidente de la nación. Su importancia institucional”, El Derecho, 19 de septiembre de 2008, 12.094.
BADENI, G., “Las funciones del vicepresidente de la Nación”, El Derecho 11 de agosto de 2008.
BAUMGARTNER, J., The American Vice Presidency Reconsidered, Westport, Praeger Publishers, 2006.
BAYH, B., Presidential Disability and Succession, Indianápolis y Nueva York, The Bobbs-Merrill Company, 1968.
BERNS, W., “The Insignificant Office. What the Framers Thought of the Vice Presidency”, National Review Online, 9 de julio de 2004, http://www.aei.org/include/pub_print.asp?pubID=20874
BIANCHI, A., Historia de la formación constitucional argentina: 1810-1860, Buenos Aires, Lexis Nexis Argentina, 2007.
BIDART CAMPOS, G., Manual de la Constitución reformada, Buenos Aires, Ediar, 1997.
BIDEGAIN, G., “Vicepresidentes en América del Sur: una agenda de investigación”, Colombia Internacional, 89, 9 de julio de 2004, pp. 159-188.
CASTRO, N., La sorprendente historia de los vicepresidentes argentinos, Buenos Aires, Javier Vergara Editor, 2009.
CHEIBUB, J. A. y F. LIMONGI, “Democratic Institutions and Regime Survival: Parliamentary and Presidential Democracies Reconsidered”, Annual Review of Political Science, 5, 2002, pp. 151-79.
EKMEKDJIÁN, M., Manual de la Constitución argentina, Buenos Aires, Depalma, 1999.
FEERICK, J., “Presidential Succession and Inability: Before and After the Twenty-Fifth Amendment”, Fordham Law Review, 79 (3) 2011, pp. 907-949.
FELIÚ. P., “Sobreviviendo a reformas, impopularidad y casos de corrupción: el presidencialismo de coalición del Brasil de Temer”, Revista de Ciencia Política, 38 (2), 2018, pp. 181-206.
GOLDSTEIN, J., The Modern American Vice Presidency. The Transformation of a Political Institution, Princeton, University Press, 1982.
GONZÁLEZ, J., El Senado federal. Su constitución, facultades y privilegios. Dictámenes y discursos parlamentarios, Buenos Aires, La Facultad, 1919.
HAMILTON, A., J. MADISON y J. JAY, El Federalista, México, Fondo de Cultura Económica, 2001 (1780).
JIMÉNEZ BARCA, A., “El partido aliado de Rousseff deja el Gobierno y aísla a la presidenta todavía más”, El País, 30 de marzo de 2016, https://elpais.com/internacional/2016/03/29/actualidad/1459264059_172547.html
JIMÉNEZ BARCA, A., “Temer busca capear su profunda impopularidad”, El País, 5 de agosto de 2016, https://elpais.com/internacional/2016/08/05/america/1470350121_159219.html
JIMÉNEZ BARCA, A., “El vicepresidente brasileño Michel Temer se ve ya como presidente”, El País, 12 de abril de 2016, https://elpais.com/internacional/2016/04/12/actualidad/1460484960_263641.html
KELSEN, H., Esencia y valor de la democracia, Barcelona y Buenos Aires, Labor, 1934.
LEVINSON, S., “The Twelfth Ammendment, National Constitution Center”, s/f, https://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/amendments/amendment-xii
LINZ, J., Democracia Presidencialista o Parlamentaria, en Consejo para la Consolidación de la Democracia, Presidencialismo vs. Parlamentarismo, Buenos Aires, Eudeba, 1988.
LINZ, J., “The Perils of Presidentialism”, Journal of Democracy, 1 (1), 1990, pp. 51-69.
LINZ, J. y A. VALENZUELA (eds.), The Failure of Presidential Democracy, vol. 2. The case of Latin America, Baltimore, The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1994.
MADDALENA, G., “Political Communication in the (Iconic) Trump Epoch”, European View, 15 (2), 2016, pp. 245-252.
MAINWARING, S., “Presidentialism, Multipartism, and Democracy. The Difficult Combination”, Comparative Political Studies, 26 (2) 1993, pp. 198-228.
MAINWARING, S. y M. SHUGART, “Juan Linz, Presidentialism and Democracy. A Critical Appraisal”, Comparative Politics, 29 (4) 1997, pp. 449-471.
MARSTEINTREDET, L., “La vicepresidencia y los problemas de la sucesión presidencial en América Latina. Viejos y nuevos retos para el presidencialismo”, Política y Gobierno, 26 (1) 2019, pp. 117-137.
MARSTEINTREDET, L. y F. UGGLA, “Allies and Traitors: Vice-Presidents in Latin America”, Journal of Latin American Studies, 2019, pp. 1-28, doi:10.1017/S0022216X18001098
MAYKA, L. R., “Bringing the Public into Policymaking: National Participatory Institutions in Latin America”, tesis doctoral, Berkeley, University of California, 2013, https://digitalassets.lib.berkeley.edu/etd/ucb/text/Mayka_berkeley_0028E_13554.pdf
MIERES, P., “Las candidaturas vicepresidenciales en las campañas electorales. El caso de Uruguay 2009”, ponencia presentada en el Cuarto Congreso de Ciencia Política de Uruguay, Montevideo, 14-16 de noviembre de 2012.
MIERES, P. y E. PAMPÍN, “La trayectoria de los vicepresidentes en los regímenes presidencialistas de América”, Revista de Estudios Políticos, 167, 2015, pp. 99-132.
NEALE, T., The Electoral College: How It Works in Contemporary Presidential Elections, CRS Report RL32611, Congressional Research Service, 2017, https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RL32611.pdf
PIGNATARO, A. y M. TAYLOR-ROBINSON, “Party competition, gender quotas, and enhanced inclusiveness in the selection of vice-presidential candidates”, Politics, Groups, and Identities, 9:4, 2021, pp. 721-738, doi: 10.1080/21565503.2019.1637354
PLOWDEN, E., Commentaries, or Reports, Londres, S. Brooke, 1816 (1571).
PURCELL, L. E. (ed.), The Vice Presidency: A Biographical Dictionary, Nueva York, Facts on File, 1998.
REDONDO, J., “Orígenes y justificación del presidencialismo americano”, Cuadernos de pensamiento político, 47, 2015, pp. 53-68.
ROSS-ACKERMAN, S., “Hyper-presidentialism: Separation of Powers without Check and Balances in Argentina and Philippines”, Berkeley Journal of International Law, 29 (1) 2011, pp. 246-333.
SCHLESINGER, A., Jr., “On the Presidential Succession”, Political Science Quarterly, 89 (3) 1974, pp. 475-505.
SERRAFERO, M., El poder y su sombra. Los vicepresidentes, Buenos Aires, Editorial de Belgrano, 1999.
SERRAFERO, M., “La vicepresidencia y las coaliciones políticas: el caso de Argentina”, Revista de Sociologia e Política, 26 (65) 2018, pp. 15-38.
SILBERDICK FEINBERG, B., Next in Line: The American Vice Presidency, Danbury, Franklin Watts, 1996.
SRIBMAN MITTELMAN, Ariel, “La vicepresidencia argentina (1983-2009)”, Cadernos de Estudos Latino-Americanos, 10, 2011.
SRIBMAN MITTELMAN, Ariel, La sucesión del poder. Una aproximación general desde experiencias de los siglos XX y XXI, Salamanca, Ediciones Universidad, 2015.
SRIBMAN MITTELMAN, Ariel, “La vicepresidencia en América Latina: un mal innecesario”, América Latina Hoy, núm. 81, 2019, pp. 51-75.
SRIBMAN MITTELMAN, Ariel, “La vicepresidencia en México: un debate pendiente”, Revista Estudios Políticos, núm. 48, 2019, pp. 73-94.
SRIBMAN MITTELMAN, Ariel, “Los principios de disponibilidad e inmediatez en la vicepresidencia latinoamericana”, Res Publica. Revista de Historia de las Ideas Políticas, vol. 24, núm. 2, 2021, pp.161-172, https://doi.org/10.5209/rpub.70008
TOCQUEVILLE, A. de, La democracia en América. 1, Madrid, Alianza, 1980 (1835).
UGGLA, F. (2020). The politics of vice-presidential selection in Latin America. Electoral Studies, 2020, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electstud.2020.102154
VINTRÓ, J., “El Rey y la investidura del Presidente del Gobierno”, Agenda Pública / El País, 21 de enero de 2016, agendapublica.elpais.com/el-rey-y-la-investidura-del-presidente-del-gobierno
WALCH, T. (ed.), At the President’s Side. The Vice Presidency in the Twentieth Century, Columbia, University of Missouri Press, 1977.
WEYLAND, K., The Politics of Market Reform in Fragile Democracies: Argentina, Brazil, Peru, and Venezuela, Princeton, University Press, 2002.
YOUNG, D., American Roulette. The History and Dilemma of the Vice Presidency, Nueva York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1972.
